| Matthew Pearce | 1791 to 1792 |
| Thomas Duff, Jr. | 1794 to 1798 |
| John Conway | 1797 to 1798 |
| Thomas Witherspoon | 1799 to 1834 |
| Thomas Stockton | 1801 to 1801 |
| William L. Mendenhall | 1835 to 1839 |
| Thomas Booth Roberts | 1839 to 1849 |
| Leonard E. Wales | 1849 to 1864 |
| Hanson Harmon | 1864 to 1869 |
| Charles G. Rumford | 1869 to 1873 |
| S. Rodman Smith | 1873 to 1903 |
| William G. Mahaffy | 1903 to 1921 |
| Henry C. Mahaffy, Jr. | 1921 to 1941 |
| Frances G. Bakey | 1941 to 1942 |
| Edward G. Pollard | 1942 to 1973 |
| Evan L. Barney | 1973 to 1978 |
| William S. Anderson, Jr. | 1979 to 1980 |
| John R. McAllister, Jr. | 1980 to 1995 |
| Peter T. Dalleo | 1995 to Present |