You are here
Opinions
The District of Delaware offers a database of opinions, listed by year, month, and judge. Below displays a list of the most recent opinions. For a more detailed search, enter the keyword or case number in the search box above.
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Pfizer Inc., et al v. Ranbaxy Laboratories Limited, et al | 03-209 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 03-209a.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Jones v. City of Wilmington, et al | 00-952 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 00-952.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
IN RE: SEARCH WARRANT (AMENDED) | 04-00079 | Chief Magistrate Judge Mary Pat Thynge | 04-00079a.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
IN RE: SEARCH WARRANT | 04-00079 | Chief Magistrate Judge Mary Pat Thynge | 04-00079.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Luckett v. Dean | 03-323 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-323.pdf | |
Brown v. Williams | 02-1443 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-1443.pdf | |
Black v. Carroll, et al | 02-144 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-144.pdf | |
Baker, et al v. Wilmington Trust | 01-819 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 01-819.pdf | |
Miller Products Co. v. Veltek Associates, et al | 01-35 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 01-35.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Vincent Allen v. Kathleen D. Feldman, et al | 03-555 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 03-555.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Graham, et al v. Taylor Capital Group, et al | 99-858 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 99-858.pdf | |
Commissariat v. Dell Computer Corp., et al | 03-484 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-484b.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Gregory S. Phillips v. Randy Parker | 01-516 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 01-516.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Rogers v. State of Delaware | 03-476 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-476.pdf | |
In Re: Integrated Telecom | 03-236 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-236.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
USA v. Joseph | 03-106 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-106.pdf | |
Enzo Life Sciences Inc. v. Digene Corporation, et al | 02-212 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 02-212.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Commissariat v. Dell Computer Corp., et al | 03-484, 03-857, 03-931, 03-1036, 04-99 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-484a.pdf | |
Callaway Golf Co. v. Dunlop Slazenger | 01-669 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 01-669a.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Frank Whalen Jr. v. Keith Ivens | 02-246 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 02-246.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Digene Corporation v. Ventana Medical Sys., et al | 01-752 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 01-752.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Cantor, et al v. Perelman, et al | 97-586 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 97-586.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
BP Amoco Chemical v. Sun Oil Company, et al | 00-82 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 00-82.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Maloney, et al v. Gordon, et al | 03-999 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-999.pdf | |
William T. Johnson v. Thomas Carroll, et al | 03-546 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 03-546.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Smith v. Noramco of Delaware, et al | 02-1615 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-1615.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Jerome Hamilton v. Faith Leavy, et al | 94-336 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 94-336.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Latonia Wojciechowski v. Jo Anne B. Barnhart | 02-263 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-263.pdf | |
Anthony A. Fooks v. Jo Anne B. Barnhart | 02-260 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-260.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Charles Stanziale v. Morris Nachtomi, et al | 01-403 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 01-403.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Johm Dillman III v. Aaron Chaffinch, et al | 02-509 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-509.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
United States of America v. Jemaine Hall | 03-100 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-100.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
United States of America v. George Stevens | 03-75 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 03-75.pdf | |
Thomas Lapinski v. Board of Education of the Brandywine School District | 00-173 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 00-173.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Robert Joseph Coleman v. State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company | 03-485 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-485.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
K. Kay Shearin v. M. Jane Bradley, et al | 03-503 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 03-503.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Hamilton v. Leavy, et al | 94-336 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 94-336.pdf | |
In Re: Montgomery Ward LLC, et al | 03-541 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 03-541.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
U.S.A. v. State of Delaware, et a | 01-020 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 01-020.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Jones v. Troop 7 State Police, et al | 03-47 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-047.pdf | |
USA v. Briscoe-Bey | 03-18 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-18.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Bartley v. Snyder, et al | 01-196 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 01-196.pdf | |
Timothy L Workman v. Barry Biles, et al | 00-1030 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 00-1030.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Liveware Publishing v. Best Software Inc., et al | 02-206 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-206.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
In Re: IT Group Inc et al | 03-932 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 03-932.pdf | |
In re: Kaiser Group International Inc., et al | 03-174, 03-175 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 03-174.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Brown v. George, et al | 02-1686 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-1686a.PDF | |
Philips Electronics, et al v. Contec Corporation, et al | 02-123 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-123a.PDF |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Brown v. George, et al | 02-1686 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-1686.pdf | |
Philips Electronics, et al v. Contec Corporation, et al | 02-123 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-123.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Mark A. Guess v. Thomas L. Carroll | 03-741 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 03-741.pdf | |
Hilda Rodriguez v. Jo Anne B. Barnhart | 03-254 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 03-0254.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Biddle v. Carroll, et al | 03-51 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-051.pdf | |
Messina, et al v. DuPont De Nemours | 02-1700 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-1700.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Pumphrey v. Baull, et al | 03-184 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-184a.pdf | |
Clyne v. Correctional Medical, et al | 01-684 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 01-684.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
EXDS Inc. v. RK Electric Inc. | 03-532 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-532.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Taylor v. Potter, et al | 02-1552, 02-1619, 02-1620 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-1552.pdf | |
Chase Mortgage Corp, et al v. Advanta Corp, et al | 01-507 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 01-507.pdf | |
Stevenson v. Snyder, et al | 00-732 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 00-732.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Hutchins v. APCC Services Inc., et al | 03-793 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-793.pdf | |
Commissariat v. Dell Computer Corp., et al | 03-484 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-484.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Watkins, et al v. New Castle County, et al | 03-791 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-791.pdf | |
Sanders v. U.S.A. | 01-603, 99-12 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 99-12.pdf | |
Seawright v. Carroll, et al | 02-1258 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-1258.pdf | |
Revel v. Carper's Task Force, et al | 00-421 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 00-421.pdf | |
Eileen A. Weaver v. Parcels Service Inc., et al | 02-1401 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 02-1401.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Arturo Laboy v. DE Correctional, et al | 02-248 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 02-248.pdf | |
Arturo Laboy v. DE Correctional, et al | 02-248 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 02-248.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Rodriguez v. Barnhart | 02-17 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-017.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
In Re: Kaiser Group Intl. | 03-38 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 03-038.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
John Macera v. Jo Anne B. Barnhart | 02-1473 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 02-1473.pdf | |
John Macera v. Jo Anne B. Barnhart | 02-1473 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 02-1473.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Enzo Diagnostics Inc v. Digene Corporation, et al | 02-212 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 02-212a.pdf | |
Thomas L. Moore v. Raphael Williams, et al | 01-330 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 01-330.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Hipkins v. Barnhart | 02-155 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-155.pdf | |
Couden, et al v. Duffy, et al | 03-369 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-369.pdf | |
Cantor, et al v. Perelman, et al | 97-586 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 97-586.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Jones Pharma Inc., et al v. KV Pharmaceutical Co. | 03-786 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 03-786.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Miller Products Co. v. Veltek Associates, et al | 01-35 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 01-35.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
United States of America v. Parris L. Wall, Jr. | 99-33-4, 03-148 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 99-033-4.pdf | |
United States of America v. Leroy Coley | 99-33-2, 03-29 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 99-033-2.pdf | |
Reach Associates, et al v. Dencer, et al | 02-1355 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 02-1355.pdf | |
In Re: Polaroid Corp et al | 02-1353 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 02-1353.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
In Re: Finova Group Inc., et al | 02-1632, 02-1633, 03-181, 03-231 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 02-1632.pdf | |
IMPAX Laboratories v. Aventis Pharma Inc. | 02-581 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 02-581.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
In Re: Philip Services DE, et al | 02-1649 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 02-1649a.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Shearin v. U.S.A | 02-266 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-266.pdf | |
AIRPORT INVESTORS LIMITED PARTNERSHIP, INC. and RICHARD SNYDER v. DOUGLAS J. NEATROUR, et al. | 03-831 | Judge Gregory M. Sleet | 03-831.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Chase Manhattan Bank v. Iridium Africa Corporation, et al | 00-564 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 00-564d.pdf | |
William E. Thornburg v. PAK 2000 Inc. | 03-824 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 03-824.pdf | |
United States of America v. Luis Manuel Valdes | 01-68, 03-764 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 01-068.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Lapinski v. Brandywine Board, et al | 00-173 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 00-173.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
INLINE CONNECTION CORPORATION v. AOL TIME WARNER INCORPORATED, et al. | 02-272 | Chief Magistrate Judge Mary Pat Thynge | 02-272.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Rhodia Chimie, et al v. PPG Industries Inc. | 01-389 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 01-389.pdf | |
Rhodia Chimie, et al v. PPG Industries Inc. | 01-389 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 01-389a.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Murphy v. Barnhart, et al | 01-651 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 01-651.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Waters v. Barnhart, et al | 01-712 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 01-712.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Montes DeOca v. U.S.A. | 01-447, 97-79 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 01-447.pdf | |
Tristrata Technology inc. v. Cardinal Health Inc., et al | 02-1290 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 02-1290.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Noble v. Becker, et al | 03-906 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-906.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
McCusker v. Neurosurgery, PA | 01-891 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 01-891.pdf | |
Ropp v. 1717 Capital Mgt Co | 02-1701 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-1701.pdf | |
eSpeed Inc., et al v. BrokerTec USA LLC, et al | 03-612 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-612.pdf | |
American Life Ins. v. Parra, et al | 98-401 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 98-401.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Jones v. City of Wilmington, et al | 00-952 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 00-952.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Merck Co Inc. v. Teva Pharmaceuticals | 01-48 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 01-048a.PDF |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Phyllis A. Purnell v. Unum Life Insurance Company of America | 02-160 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 02-160.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
PAUL RITTER v. ANTHONY COOPER, II and MARY COOPER | 02-1435 | Judge Gregory M. Sleet | 02-1435.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
American Life Ins. v. Parra, et al | 98-401 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 98-401.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Harris v. Christina School District | 02-253 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-253.pdf | |
In Re: Kaiser Aluminum Corp, et al | 02-1580 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 02-1580.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Wendy Miller v. Daimler Chrysler Corporation | 01-827 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 01-827.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
CSX Transportation v. DE Dept of Trans., et al | 03-756 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-756.pdf | |
Thomas v. Connecticut General | 02-136 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-mc-136.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Liquidation Trust, et al v. Fleet Retail Finance, et al | 00-840 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 00-840.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Carroll v. Comm Social Security, et al | 01-105 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 01-105.pdf | |
William Bullen v. L. Aaron Chaffinch et al | 02-1315 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 02-1315.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Alvin Emory v. AstraZeneca Pharm LP | 02-1466 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 02-1466.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
USA v. Ramirez-Gonzales | 03-47 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-47.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Phillips v. Bird, et al | 03-247 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-247.pdf | |
Callaway Golf Co. v. Dunlop Slazenger | 01-669 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 01-669.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Commissariat v. Dell Computer Corp., et al | 03-484 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-484.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Constar Int.'l v. Continental Pet Tech | 99-234 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 99-234.pdf | |
In Re: Trico Steel Company, et al | 02-1500 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 02-1500.pdf | |
In Re: DaimlerChrysler, et al | 00-993 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 00-993.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Brooks v. Price | 02-230 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-230.pdf | |
Brittingham v. Barnhart | 02-459 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 02-459.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
MYLAN PHARMACEUTICALS, INC.,et al. v. KREMERS URBAN DEVELOPMENT, et al. | 02-1628 | Judge Gregory M. Sleet | 02-1628.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
MICHAEL B. CUSTER v. NEWROADS, INC. | 02-1490 | Judge Gregory M. Sleet | 02-1490.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Safas Corporation v. Etura Premier LLC | 01-833 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 01-833a.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Thomas v. Connecticut General | 02-136 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-mc-136.PDF |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
In Re: Harnischfeger et al | 03-607 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 03-607.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Spark v. MBNA Corp., et al | 96-497 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 96-497.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Pell, et al v. E.I. DuPont, et al | 02-21 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-21.pdf | |
Summit Metals Inc. v. Gray, et al | 00-387 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 00-387.pdf | |
Murphy v. Carrol, et al | 02-1602 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 02-1602.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
In Re: DaimlerChrysler, et al | 00-993, 00-984, 01-004 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 00-993.pdf | |
HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL, INC., et al. v. UNIVERSAL AVIONICS SYSTEMS CORP., et al. | 02-359 | Chief Magistrate Judge Mary Pat Thynge | 02-359a.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Chase Manhattan v. Iridium Africa Corp., et al | 00-564 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 00-564.pdf | |
UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. BONNIE FOSTER | 03-74 | Chief Magistrate Judge Mary Pat Thynge | 03-74.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
American Life Ins. v. Parra, et al | 98-401 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 98-401.pdf | |
Miller Products Co. v. Veltek Associates, et al | 01-35 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 01-35.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
HONEYWELL INTERNATIONAL, INC., et al. v. UNIVERSAL AVIONICS SYSTEMS CORP., et al. | 02-359 | Chief Magistrate Judge Mary Pat Thynge | 02-359.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Rhodia Chimie, et al v. PPG Industries Inc | 01-389 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 01-389a.pdf | |
Miller Products Co. v. Veltek Associates, et al | 01-35 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 01-35a.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
In Re: Montgomery Ward LLC, et al | 01-192, 01-249 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 01-192.pdf | |
VERNON E. THOMPSON v. DOVER DOWNS, INC. | 02-1360 | Chief Magistrate Judge Mary Pat Thynge | 02-1360.pdf | |
WILLIAM JOSEPH WEBB, JR. v. THOMAS L. CARROLL | 02-583 | Judge Gregory M. Sleet | 02-583.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Bell Communications v. Fore Systems Inc. | 98-586 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 98-586.pdf | |
USA v. Davis | 03-38 | Judge Joseph J. Farnan, Jr. | 03-38.pdf |
Case | Judge | File | ||
---|---|---|---|---|
Dillman v. Chaffinch, et al | 02-509 | Judge Kent A. Jordan | 02-509.pdf |